6 min read

Civil Air Patrol Credits Katrina With Coming-of-Age in Which Lucky Cessnas Photographed a Drowned City Until FEMA Started Calling First

The Civil Air Patrol 85th Anniversary Series has reached week seven, the installment in which a Category 5 hurricane is asked to double as a capability brief. The timeline tile is titled “After Katrina: How One Storm Reshaped Civil Air Patrol’s Disaster Response,” which is the preferred phrasing for a drowned city that later proved useful in meetings.

On Aug. 29, 2005, the levees failed and Col. Rock Palermo’s Louisiana Wing unit found itself on the far side of the state from the storm’s path, a geographic accident the anniversary copy files under operations. His crew left Lake Charles at first light and flew toward New Orleans while most of the country was still watching it on television. They were among the first fixed-wing aircraft in the area, a distinction conferred by not being where the hurricane was.

There was no air traffic control. Standard radios were down. Palermo’s crew talked plane to plane with Coast Guard and Army National Guard helicopter pilots pulling people off rooftops and overpasses, watched for collisions the old-fashioned way, and marked where large numbers of people were stranded so someone with a hoist would know where to land. Their Cessna was one of a handful in the national fleet with a satellite-transmitted digital imaging system, which in 2005 counted as a specialized capability and in week seven of an anniversary series counts as the plot.

First Lt. Scott Hunsaker, the photographer, had family and work ties to the area and therefore possessed the uncommon emergency-services credential of knowing what the city was supposed to look like. “The destruction was obvious and the scene was surreal,” he later told CAP VOLUNTEER magazine. “I think the scope of the damage took a few minutes to sink in.” The images, sent in near-real time to the state emergency operations center in Baton Rouge, did not require the damage to sink in. They required only that it still be there when the shutter opened.

Coming of Age, Defined as Someone Else’s Org Chart

Katrina killed at least 1,833 people, caused $108 billion in damage, left up to 300,000 homes destroyed or uninhabitable, and flooded nearly 80 percent of New Orleans. Civil Air Patrol’s subsequent literature has treated those figures as the backdrop against which 1,800 members from 17 wings logged more than 50,000 volunteer hours, flew nearly 1,000 missions, and delivered more than 2,000 time-critical pictures of schools, hospitals, and other buildings emergency managers needed to see because driving there had become theoretical.

It was, the series reports, the first time CAP units were fully integrated into a joint task force during a real-world contingency — Joint Task Force Katrina, then Joint Task Force Rita, the Gulf not having finished making its point. First Army Lt. Gen. Russel Honoré was photographed briefing Col. Palermo, which is how a volunteer flying club confirms it was in the room. Richard L. Anderson, a former CAP national commander later serving as assistant secretary of the Air Force for manpower and reserve affairs, said that was when the Air Force, FEMA, and state emergency managers “saw the value of Civil Air Patrol” and its Cessnas, which could still use airfields flooding had reduced to a technicality.

Lt. Col. Amos Plante of the Louisiana Wing offered a less doctrinal account in 2015: “We were lucky.” Most of the wing’s planes had been in the northern part of the state for emergency services training. The fleet was intact. Anniversary series prefer not to lead with luck.

Col. Mark Lahan, now CAP’s interim director of operations, was serving in the U.S. Army in New Orleans during the storm. Before Katrina, he said, “you couldn’t pre-position for a disaster. You had to wait till it hit and the governor asked.” The reforms that followed changed “how response is done across the country. Not just us, but everybody.” The organization has spent the years since making sure “not just us” remains a group photograph that includes unpaid people in Cessnas.

Water, Oil, Lava, Fire: The Camera Stays

John W. Desmarais Sr., a former CAP director of operations, said the 2004 hurricane season had already pushed the organization toward “a more forward-leaning posture,” and that Katrina finished the argument. The structural claim is that 52 loosely connected wings became “one interoperable organization deploying as a team system that can backfill itself,” which is how a volunteer outfit learns to write like a contractor. When FEMA now expects a major storm, surge funding can task CAP under Title 10 and move people, aircraft, and vehicles into place before landfall — a fundamental difference from the crew that had to wait for the water and then take pictures of it.

The subsequent disasters arrived on schedule and were met with better optics. After Deepwater Horizon exploded April 20, 2010, 150 members flew 54 aircraft for 120 days, logging 1,010 sorties and 2,387 hours photographing shoreline, booms, cleanup crews, and sheen until Col. James M. Rushing, then Southeast Region commander, called it CAP’s largest mission since World War II, a comparison that does a great deal of work with very little combat. Hawaii Wing crews later photographed Kilauea’s lava for the U.S. Geological Survey. The CAP Geospatial Program, founded in 2019, put trained members — including cadets — on home computers to assess damage for FEMA, sometimes before responders arrived, an efficient use of unpaid labor and a striking promotion from Hunsaker’s cockpit. After the August 2023 Maui wildfires, the team assessed roughly 2,000 homes and businesses in Lahaina and Kula, found more than 1,800 damaged or destroyed, and helped build a map that reached the president. On Oct. 4, 2022, a Missouri Wing drone team produced imagery that led rescuers to a person trapped in a Florida mangrove swamp after Hurricane Ian; FEMA credited the save. Starlink is next, Lahan said, so crews can stream video “regardless of what the communications situation on the ground is.” Desmarais expects artificial intelligence to choose the pictures and grade them faster, until dissemination is “truly” near-real-time, a word that has been chasing the files since Baton Rouge.

Lessons Incorporated

Anderson has no doubt another storm on Katrina’s scale is coming, a forecast that does not require a historical timeline. What CAP will bring, he said, is the ability to deploy multiple wings at once and radio teams that become “literally the only communications in and out of those communities” when the towers fail — the problem Palermo’s crew solved by talking to helicopters out the window, now with better letterhead.

“The lessons of Katrina,” Anderson said, “have been incorporated into current-day operations.” Twenty-one years after a Louisiana Cessna flew into uncontrolled airspace over a drowning city, the organization that got there because it was on the other side of the state has cameras that cover huge areas, analysts who never leave their desks, funding language that lets it pre-position, and a commemorative series that presents each later catastrophe as further evidence the pictures mattered. Palermo died in an aircraft accident in 2021. The Cessnas kept flying. The anniversary series has several tiles left.